Refinance or Stay? Comparing an Existing Facility Against a New One

Refinance or Stay? Comparing an Existing Facility Against a New One

Domira Team March 25, 2025 3 min read

A lower rate elsewhere is not automatically a better deal. What to count before moving a facility.

Refinancing is marketed on the rate difference, which is the easiest figure to advertise and the least complete. The decision depends on costs to move, remaining term and what the new arrangement changes beyond the rate.

Stay with the existing facility at a glance

Continue under current terms, avoiding the costs and process of moving while accepting whatever the current arrangement costs.

Refinance to a new facility at a glance

Settle the existing facility with a new one on different terms, incurring the costs of moving in exchange for improved terms.

Cost to move

Stay with the existing facility: None. This is the advantage of staying and it is often understated in refinancing comparisons.

Refinance to a new facility: Settlement costs, new arrangement costs, valuation and registration, all incurred before any saving begins.

Time for savings to accumulate

Stay with the existing facility: Not applicable, though the existing cost continues.

Refinance to a new facility: Requires a break-even period. A short remaining term rarely justifies the move.

Process and effort

Stay with the existing facility: None.

Refinance to a new facility: A full application including assessment, valuation and documentation, with the possibility of decline.

Flexibility to restructure

Stay with the existing facility: Limited to what variations the current provider permits.

Refinance to a new facility: An opportunity to change term, amount or structure, which can matter more than the rate.

Risk of a worse outcome

Stay with the existing facility: None, beyond continuing the current cost.

Refinance to a new facility: A new assessment could produce less favourable terms if circumstances have changed.

When stay with the existing facility wins

  • The remaining term is short, so a rate saving has little time to accumulate.
  • Settlement and new arrangement costs would consume the benefit.
  • The existing terms include features that suit you.
  • Your circumstances have changed in ways that would make a new assessment unfavourable.

When refinance to a new facility wins

  • A substantial remaining term over which savings accumulate.
  • A meaningful difference in cost, not a marginal one.
  • You want to change the term or restructure the obligation.
  • Your profile has improved since the original arrangement.

How to decide

Refinance when the remaining term is long enough for the saving to exceed the cost of moving with a clear margin, or when you need to restructure rather than merely reduce the rate. Stay when the remaining term is short or the difference is marginal.

Calculate the break-even: total cost of moving divided by the monthly saving gives the number of months before you are ahead. If that period is a significant portion of the remaining term, the move is not worth the effort or the risk.

If you are weighing a financing decision, Domira can review the offers, model the total cost and stress test the obligation with you before you sign anything.

Frequently Asked Questions

How much rate difference justifies refinancing?

There is no general threshold, because it depends on the remaining term, the outstanding amount and the cost of moving. Calculate the break-even period for your specific situation, which takes a few minutes and answers the question directly.

Can I refinance with the same provider?

Often you can request a review or restructure, and providers sometimes prefer retaining a customer to losing one. It is worth asking before applying elsewhere, since an internal variation typically involves fewer costs than moving.

Does refinancing restart the term?

It can, and that is a significant point. A new facility over a fresh long term may reduce the monthly payment while increasing the total substantially. If the objective is lower cost rather than lower payments, keep the remaining term rather than extending it.

Complimentary Consultation

Have a Property Question?

Domira can help you navigate property, financing and investment decisions in Saudi Arabia. Speak with our team for an initial consultation.