A valuation for security purposes answers a different question from the one buyers ask. Six assumptions worth correcting.
Buyers are frequently surprised when a financier's valuation differs from the price they negotiated. The two figures are produced for different purposes under different assumptions, and understanding the difference prevents both surprise and poor decisions.
How to test a claim like this
Test any expectation about a valuation by asking what question it answers. A valuation for lending answers what the property would secure; a valuation for sale answers what it might achieve. Those are not the same question.
Myth 1: The valuation should equal the price I agreed
Reality: The agreed price reflects what one buyer would pay in one negotiation. The valuation reflects an opinion of value under defined assumptions, which can differ in either direction.
How to check it yourself: Ask what comparable transactions were used and whether they are genuinely comparable to your property.
Myth 2: A low valuation means I am overpaying
Reality: It may, and it may also reflect limited comparable evidence, a conservative basis or property characteristics the valuer weighted differently.
How to check it yourself: Review the comparables. If they are genuinely similar and recent, the valuation is telling you something worth hearing.
Myth 3: I can choose the valuer
Reality: Financiers usually appoint the valuer, because the valuation is prepared for their purposes rather than yours.
How to check it yourself: Ask whether you may obtain your own valuation as well, and understand that it serves your decision rather than their assessment.
Myth 4: A valuation below the price ends the purchase
Reality: It usually means a smaller amount is available, and the gap must be funded from your own resources or the price renegotiated.
How to check it yourself: Calculate the shortfall and decide whether you can or should fund it before treating the transaction as dead.
Myth 5: Improvements I plan will be reflected
Reality: A valuation generally reflects the property as it stands, not as you intend it to become.
How to check it yourself: Ask whether any valuation on the intended completed condition is available where relevant, particularly for renovation projects.
Myth 6: The valuation is a guarantee of value
Reality: It is an opinion at a date under stated assumptions, prepared for a specific purpose, and markets move afterwards.
How to check it yourself: Read the assumptions and the date. Both limit what the figure means for any other decision.
What this changes in your decision
- Understand what purpose the valuation serves before reacting to the figure.
- Review the comparables used and whether they fit your property.
- Calculate the funding gap if the valuation is below the price.
- Obtain your own valuation where the decision warrants it.
- Note the date and assumptions, since both limit the figure's application.
If you are weighing a financing decision, Domira can review the offers, model the total cost and stress test the obligation with you before you sign anything.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can I challenge a valuation used for financing?
You can usually request the basis and provide additional transaction evidence, particularly where the valuer may not have had access to recent comparable sales. A reasoned submission with better data is sometimes accepted; disagreement without evidence generally is not.
Do I pay for the financier's valuation?
Commonly the cost is passed to the applicant as part of the arrangement costs. Ask whether the valuation is transferable if you move to a different provider, since repeating it is an avoidable expense.
Should I get my own valuation before buying?
For a significant purchase, particularly where comparable evidence is thin or the property is unusual, an independent valuation prepared for your decision is often worth its cost. It answers your question rather than the financier's.
Have a Property Question?
Domira can help you navigate property, financing and investment decisions in Saudi Arabia. Speak with our team for an initial consultation.